After the scandal - managing corporate firestorms

Consumption happens increasingly with the future in mind. Consumers buy groceries to cook later that day. They purchase a gym membership, seeking to become healthier and body-beautiful in 90 days. They buy a home to prepare for settling down over the next decade.

It’s caring for this imagined future that sits at the heart of consumer society.

Consumers anticipate results

Markets are not only about the immediate quality of the product or service, usage situation, and brand names, but also about the end benefits that a consumer looks forward to. It’s these anticipated results that make consumption meaningful.

For example, the advertised end benefit of a nutritional supplement is the aspiration of a having a perfect physique that will be admired. The end benefit of a bank account is to have money and to afford something. Car advertisements target a consumer’s desire for status or escape from the humdrum of the status quo.

An end benefit is the ultimate outcome of using a product or service. It’s all about hope: hope that a negative future is avoided or a positive future is attained.

Protecting the Future

Volkswagen Logo

This intense, future-focused, orientation among consumers, may explain why corporate controversies are endemic in our consumer-led society. It may also help to explain how to manage such events once they occur.

The destructive capacity of a true corporate firestorm is not only in its ability to ruin careers and generate bad PR, but also, its ability to shape or even destroy consumers' expectations about the society in which they exist.

The corporate firestorm destroys the perceived hopes and futures of consumers, and corporate scandals wreck the setting in which consumer aspirations are located: the future.

A few examples of companies and organisation that have recently seen their reputations damaged by corporate news firestorms are:

  • Deliveroo
  • Volkswagen
  • FIFA
  • Samsung
  • Uber
  • HSBC
  • Royals Royce

But how does the corporate firestorm affect a consumer’s perceived future?

The Volkswagen emissions debacle ruined their reputation as a responsible automobile manufacturer and left consumers questioning if their cars had played a part in climate change.

Coverage of HSBC’s infamous relationship with the Sinaloa cartel in Mexico, brought the question of the safety to the minds of society. HSBC customers were forced to consider the effects of gang activities and drug dealing.

The loss of a consumer’s perceived future immediately accrues three costs that corporate reputation management should address and communicate.

    1. Lost opportunity costs for the consumer – the future that didn’t happen

This is the cost of the knowing there was a better future for the consumer that could have been, but didn’t manifest. Rather than only addressing the moral regret the corporation may have, communication should also address the regrets the consumer is feeling; acknowledging and coming to terms with the consumer’s lost dreams, hopes and the unwanted change to their end benefits.

    1. The consumer’s transaction costs – managing new future goal

This is the cost the consumer has in planning the new anticipated timeline. Because the consumer must now spend efforts gathering information, planning and envisioning a new future, communication should support this cognitive expenditure. In terms of communication this means painting new pictures of the future and providing information.

    1. Consumer ‘hysteresis’ – assisting in reforming consumer identities

Because the world has regularities, consumers know what to do and what their roles are. Consumers understand who they are. When the future suddenly changes because of the corporate firestorm, it not only brings the surroundings into question, but also who they are, what they do, and what their roles are?

For example, what does it mean to be a VW owner after the emissions scandal? The consumer is left in a state of ‘hysteresis’ - lagging in identity formation. Corporate communications must assist the consumer to become his or her new self.

Recreating the future: accountability and governance

Man being interviewed by the press

In the face of a scandal, those responsible for reputation management must of course address corporate accountability and governance. Leaders should focus on improving ethical cultures, and addressing production processes and quality control.

However, leaders, and the organisations they manage, also need to address the loss of their consumer’s perceived futures. They must let their customers in on what direction their companies are going. They must also redress the costs of time that appear from the loss of the future. Only then will new end benefits emerge and consumer faith can begin to be restored.

If corporate leaders do not respect the basic nature of reputation management within their markets and address the risks or changes to their customers’ end benefits, they risk prolonging or exacerbating the crisis.

The only option in the face of corporate reputation crisis is to bring consumer hope back into the game by recreating the future in which consumers hope to exist.

Dr Thomas Robinson is a Lecturer in Marketing at Cass Business School, City, University of London.

His research in the field of Consumer Culture Theory, centres on the role of culture and temporality in the market, especially how the experience of time differs from setting to setting and how this informs consumer processes.

Find out more about the Cass Marketing Group.

Definition
Hysteresis

A situation which arises when any historical event affects the future economic path. Any disturbance in an economy will lead to a trickle down effect, and the problem will persist. This rolling down impact is known as the hysteresis effect.

Tags Cass Business School,Cass,corporate firestorm,scandals,relationship management
https://www.city.ac.uk
managing corporate firestorms
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
I recommend
No recommendations yet

Comments

Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Society
Thames Water said the Beast from the East and summer heatwave had an impact on its ability to meet leakage targets as it reported interim pre-tax profits crashing to £67.7 million from £218.5 million a year ago. The water company also revealed the extreme weather sent complaints soaring as it battled supply interruptions, with written customer complaints jumping to 11,083 in the half-year to September 30 from 8,242 a year earlier. Thames Water was ordered...
Society
A British tourist has gone missing in New Zealand, sparking an international appeal for help from her family. Grace Millane was last seen in Auckland on Saturday night (Dec 1), and has not been in contact with her family since - despite her 22nd birthday being on Sunday. Her family, from Basildon in Essex, have alerted the British Embassy in New Zealand and reported her missing to police in Auckland, as well as sharing 'missing' posters on social media. De...
Society
The main reason for sickness absence in the London Fire Brigade is now stress, anxiety and depression, Commissioner Dany Cotton has said. LFB has seen a "small increase" in the number of days taken off as sick leave over the last three years, Ms Cotton, the brigade's most senior firefighter, said. It is the first time mental health has been the leading cause of the absences, she told the London Assembly on Thursday. LFB employed four extra counsellors foll...
Incidents
A 77-year-old woman who collapsed while calling police to report a burglary at her home is critically ill in hospital. She dialled 999 on Monday to report intruders had forced their way into her home in Bells Hill, High Barnet, north-east London, and stolen property. During the call, the police operator heard her collapse. Paramedics arrived and she was taken to hospital, where her family remains at her bedside. Scotland Yard said its Homicide and Major Cr...
Society
A medieval skeleton wearing a pair of thigh-high leather boots has been found during excavations for London's new sewer. The skeleton was discovered face down in mud at the Chambers Wharf site in Bermondsey during work to create the Thames Tideway Tunnel. Archaeologists believe the man may have died during the late 15th Century while carrying out work near the river. MOLA Headland Infrastructure said it was a "rare" and "fascinating" find. The consortium i...
Society
Christmas lights in an upmarket shopping street were taken down after just three days by council inspectors who branded them a “death trap”. The decorations were put up in Primrose Hill by Jonny Bucknell, the son of the UK’s first DIY television star Barry Bucknell, with a switch-on ceremony on Sunday by model Jo Wood, ex-wife of Rolling Stones guitarist Ronnie, and singer-songwriter Collette Cooper. But on Wednesday, Camden council bosses removed and impo...
Society
More than 130,000 children across Great Britain will spend Christmas in temporary accommodation, official figures suggest. One in every 103 under-18s is officially homeless, a 59% rise in five years, housing charity Shelter said. One mother-of-three said her children were preparing for Christmas in a one-room bed and breakfast for the second year running. Councils said a lack of housing had left them "struggling to cope". Using government statistics, Shelt...
News Company
Thanks to the groundbreaking partnership between MoneyTO and the Polish company South Link Commerce, it's now faster and easier to make online money transfers from the UK to Polish bank accounts. The deal between the two companies was finalized at Fintech 360 conference, the annual gathering of financial innovators, in Vienna, Austria. As Polish is the most common non-British nationality in the UK, with an estimated total of 1 million Poles making Britain...
Society
A treetop adventure course popular with Cara Delevingne and Mo Farah has extended its after-dark sessions after a surge in demand.  Go Ape in Battersea has opened up one of its high-rope challenges from 5pm until 6.30pm so daredevils can test their climbing skills in darkness. Olympic legend Farah scaled the 50ft-high course with his family this month. Other celebrity adventurers have included grime star Stormzy and actors Will Ferrell, David Schwimmer and...