Teacher who secretly filmed students’ bodies has acquittal upheld

A high school teacher who used a camera pen to secretly video female students’ chest areas did so for sexual purposes, but his acquittal on voyeurism charges will nevertheless stand, Ontario’s top court ruled in a split decision on Thursday.

In dismissing a prosecution challenge to a lower court verdict, the Court of Appeal found the students had no reasonable expectation of privacy — a key element of the offence of voyeurism - writes lfpress.com.

London police charged the English teacher, Ryan Jarvis, over secret recordings he made in 2010 and 2011 of the students while he was chatting with them. The images, captured in various places in and around the school and lasting from seconds to a few minutes, involved 27 female students aged 14 to 18.

Jarvis taught at H.B. Beal secondary school. Another teacher spotted what was happening and alerted the principal, who observed the same conduct and called in the police.

Key to the voyeurism charge was that several of the videos, admitted as evidence at trial, focused on the teens’ chest areas.

In November 2015, Superior Court Justice Andrew Goodman found Jarvis not guilty, despite deciding his behaviour had been “morally repugnant and professionally objectionable.” While Goodman ruled the students had a reasonable expectation of privacy, he found the videos were not sexually motivated.

Among other things, Goodman said, Jarvis had no other pornographic material, sometimes filmed faces, and none of the images showed nudity or sexual activity. The judge also noted that the images showed what could be “readily seen” by anyone.

“While a conclusion that the accused was photographing the students’ cleavage for a sexual purpose is most likely,” Goodman found, “there may be other inferences to be drawn.”

The Crown appealed, arguing it should have been a no-brainer that Jarvis, who did not testify, had been sexually motivated: The subjects were females, and the camera was deliberately pointed downward at their breasts.

In coming to opposite conclusions than Goodman did — but still upholding the acquittal — the majority of the Appeal Court panel that heard the case rejected his analysis of the sexual aspect, which leaned on parallels to child pornography. Goodman was wrong, the higher court ruled, to consider the lack of nudity as negating the sexual purposes Jarvis had.

The judge also failed to identify what other purposes the teacher might have had, the higher court said.

“This was an overwhelming case of videos focused on young women’s breasts and cleavage,” Justice Kathryn Feldman wrote on behalf of herself and Justice David Watt.

However, in looking at the second element of the offence, Feldman and Watt disagreed with Goodman that the teens had a reasonable expectation of privacy at school even though they could be recorded, for example, by security cameras.

In coming to that conclusion, the majority noted that we live in an open society “where visual interaction is part of everyday life and is valued” and that while school should be a protected and safe environment, students know they can be observed in places where they gather.

“If a person is in a public place, fully clothed and not engaged in toileting or sexual activity, they will normally not be in circumstances that give rise to a reasonable expectation of privacy,” the court ruled.

In a dissenting opinion, Justice Grant Huscroft agreed the videos were for a sexual purpose but rejected the privacy conclusion.

“Privacy expectations need not be understood in an all-or-nothing fashion,” Huscroft said, drawing on an example of a mother breast-feeding in public. “There is a reasonable expectation that she will not be visually recorded surreptitiously for a sexual purpose.”

In saying he would have convicted Jarvis, Huscroft said the students did have a reasonable expectation of privacy despite being easily observed in public.

“The students’ interest in privacy is entitled to priority over the interests of anyone who would seek to compromise their personal and sexual integrity while they are at school,” Huscroft said.

Jarvis’s licence to teach was suspended in 2013 for failing to pay his dues. There is no record of disciplinary findings against him, according to the Ontario College of Teachers.

Read more news of London on our site.

Teacher students`bodies Londonpolice
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
7 views in september
I recommend
No recommendations yet

Comments

Comments are designed to communicate and discuss the features of an enterprise or event, as well as to find out the interesting questions on it.

Society
A pioneering geneticist has died in hospital after she was involved in a crash witha cab and another vehicle while cycling in London. Professor Maria Bitner-Glindzicz, 55, who died on Thursday, was a professor of human and molecular genetics at the Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health, linked to University College London . She was involved in a crash with a cab and a stationary vehiclewhile cycling in Clerkenwell on Wednesday morning. Scotland Yar...
Society
A father is set to take on London’s biggest exercise challenges over the next 12 months in a bid to raise more than £50,000 in memory of his son who died six days after he was born. Darren Smith’s son Isaac died in August 2012 following time in neonatal intensive care for brain cooling, a therapy used to prevent brain damage in newborns. The year after he died, the 39-year-old, from Enfield , ran the London Marathon, raising nearly £30,000 for the Evelina...
Society
A studentwho arrived late at school had a good excuse — he had been helping to save the life of a pensioner who had collapsed in the street. Tejinder Purewal, 16, gave CPR chest compressions to 72-year-old Antonio Fernandes as he lay in Bath Road, Hounslow , after being alerted by the screams of a passer-by. Tejinder, pictured, had received basic life-saving training from St John Ambulance as part of his activities as a school army cadet. Tonight he will b...
Society
A new baby girl was brought into the world with the help of three London police officers in Kentish Town. The trio of bobbies assisted new mum Weihong Yu in giving birth after she went into labourin Kentish Town Road on Sunday night. PC Burch, PC Williams and PC King arrived at 9.27pm to help Ms Yu, who gave birth just five minutes later at 9.32pm. The London Ambulance Service arrived atthe scene just a minute later and whisked the newborn, who is yet to b...
Society
An ambitious target to build 3,700 new council homes by 2025 has been scrapped, in a blow to Mayor Sadiq Khan’s pledge to tackle the capital’s housing crisis. The City of London Corporation announced the plan in 2015 but has now quietly abandoned any hope of hitting the deadline, following a series of setbacks, delays and mounting costs - writes standard.co.uk Only 62 homes were completed in the first three years and the Square Mile’s local authority has n...
Incidents
A man arrested at Buckingham Palace on suspicion of possessing a Taser has been released by police. The 38-year-old, a visitor to London from the Netherlands, was detained at the visitors' entrance to the palace at about 12:45 BST on Sunday - writes bbc.com Scotland Yard said his possession of the device, which was low-powered and part of a keyring, was a genuine error, and that he posed no threat. The man was released without further action. A spokesman s...
Incidents
A woman has been charged with the murder of her 75-year-old husband at their home in east London. Kanagusabi Ramathan was found with serious head injuries after paramedics attended a property in Burges Road, Newham, at about 14:20 BST on Friday. Packiam Ramathan, 73, has been remanded in custody and is due to appear at Thames Magistrates' Court on Monday. A post-mortem examination and formal identification will be carried out in due course, police said. Re...
Politics
Labour says it would scrap laws allowing private landlords to evict tenants without giving a reason. The law, in force since 1988, is thought to be the biggest cause of homelessness. Labour's shadow housing minister John Healey will announce the policy at the party's conference later. He will also unveil plans for a £20m fund to set up "renters unions" to support tenants in disputes with landlords. So-called "no-fault" evictions - when landlords throw peop...
Society
From an early age, children are asked about what they would like to do when they grow up. Their answers - and the jobs they go on to do - reveal some striking differences. From sportsperson to vet to lawyer, the UK's children have their sights set on ambitious jobs - writes bbc.com But a closer look at the aspirations of boys and girls from different ethnic backgrounds shows that some are aiming higher than others. Until now, we have known very little abou...