House of Lords under fire as peers who didn't speak once claim almost half a million in expenses

'The problems of Britain’s broken upper house continue to fester,' says Electoral Reform Society.

Campaigners have criticised “couch-potato peers” in the House of Lords who took part in less than a quarter of votes and did not speak at all in 2016-17, but still claimed a total of £462,510 in tax-free expenses - writes independent.co.uk.

The 33 peers also did not table a written question or sit on a committee though claimed an average £14,015 each, or £746 per vote, the Electoral Reform Society (ERS) said in a new report.

The top eight “claimed more than UK average take-home pay”, the ERS asserted. In total 455 peers claimed at this level during the 141-day session, with daily allowance and travel costs coming to more than £19m for the whole chamber, it added.

Darren Hughes, the ERS’s chief executive, said: “Despite some minor reforms, the problems of Britain’s broken upper house continue to fester. With nearly one in 10 unelected peers failing to contribute in key ways – despite many of them picking up large sums – we have a democratic crisis in our second chamber.

“The vast majority of party-affiliated peers toe the line, while many crossbench peers simply don’t turn up. The so-called ‘independent’ chamber is packed full of party loyalists.

“Politicians must now meet the challenge before this crumbling, crony-stuffed house declines even further. Voters want real change. It’s time for both MPs and peers to embrace it.”

Calling for reform, the report said the top 300 voting peers accounted for two-thirds of all votes while “lobby-fodder lords” largely stuck to party lines, with 78 per cent of Conservatives failing to rebel and the average Labour peer opposing the Government in 90 per cent of votes last year.

A significant proportion of non-aligned crossbench peers – 41 per cent – voted fewer than 10 times in 2016-17, compared with7 per cent for Tories and 14 per cent for Labour.

The chamber is also crammed with former MPs, MEPs and council leaders, the ERS said.

A House of Lords spokeswoman said: “The Electoral Reform Society’s supposedly ‘devastating analysis of the state of the House of Lords’ is a rehash of publicly available parliamentary data that they have published previously.

“Their comparison of members’ claims to average take home pay is undermined by their inclusion of members’ travel costs, which are receipted and are not in any way comparable to a salary.

“It is reasonable that peers can claim allowances to cover the costs they incur when they contribute to the work of Parliament. Members can claim £300 or £150 for every day they attend the House and undertake parliamentary work.

“They are expected to pay for any costs associated with attending the House such as their London accommodation and staff costs from this allowance.”

The Lords should be restricted to 300 “fairlyelected” members, ERS said. It added: “We must see parties commit to a far smaller, proportionallyelected upper house.

“At a time of significantconstitutional, economic and political change, the need for an effective House of Peers or Senate is overwhelming.”

Read more news of London on our site.

independent.co.uk
HouseofLordsunderfire London
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
5 views in august
I recommend
No recommendations yet

Comments

Comments are designed to communicate and discuss the features of an enterprise or event, as well as to find out the interesting questions on it.

Society
Soaring rents are costing London families more than £300 extra a month compared with eight years ago, it was claimed today. One million private renters are having to find £3,600 a year more, costing households £3.8 billion. The scale of the squeeze was revealed in figures produced by Labour to support its policy of rent controls - writes standard.co.uk Shadow housing secretary John Healey said rent rises since 2010 have cost families in England and Wales a...
Society
In a first, shoppers in south London can now buy groceries in Sainsbury’s without going to the checkout or self-service scanner. By just using their phone, shoppers can skip the queue all together and scan what they need themselves in the Clapham North branch of the chain store. The supermarket is trialling a new scan, pay and go technology that will enable customers to buy products by scanning them on their smart phone. The trial is thought to be the firs...
Society
A parrot stuck on aLondon rooftreatedfirefighters who came to its aid this morning with a torrent of expletives, it is claimed. Officers from the London Fire Brigade were called to rescue Jessie the Macaw parrot, who had spent three days languishing on a neighbour's roof after escapingher home in Cuckoo Hall Lane, Edmonton. The firefighters were called amid concerns for Jessie's welfareafter owners and the RSPCAfailed to get her down. Inan effort to bond w...
Society
New fingerprint scanners are set to be rolled out across London, giving Met Police officers greater power than ever to identify members of the public in the street. A number of forces have used similar devices since 2012 but the UK's largest police force has developed its own technology , dropping the cost so it can roll out six times as many scanners in the field. The cheaper product means that 600 of the Met's 30,000 officers can run a suspect's fingerpr...
Society
Hundredsof fish have died inLondon rivers as the hot weatherconcentrates pollution in the water, environmentalists said today. The heat has caused extremely low water levels and depleted oxygen, which is crucial for marine life  - writes standard.co.uk The affected waterways includeBeverley Brook, which runs through Richmond Park , the Wandle in south-west London, and the River Lea and River Roding in the east. Images taken by the Moo Canoes clean-up team...
Incidents
'He would come up behind her and whisper in her ear as an excuse to get too close to her'. The girl, who was 16 when she started, was sexually harassed, intimidated and had her hours cut after she rejected her supervisor's advances. She was working 10 hours a week as a receptionist at Pizza Hut Delivery when she was targeted by Sultan Tanha - writes independent.co.uk Stratford employment tribunal in east London ruled he subjected her to "unjustified threat...
Society
A British holidaymaker has died following a suspected fight in a popular tourist resort on the Spanish island of Ibiza . The man, named by local police as 23-year-old Conor Lee, is thought to have died following an altercation with a group of men in San Antonio in the early hours of Sunday morning - writes independent.co.uk Police have now launched an investigation into the death of the man, who was understood to be staying at the Bergatin Hotel around 10...
Society
Rail commuters are being warned to expect a 3.5 per cent fare increase in 2019, which could see passengers on some longer distance routes paying up to £150 more each year for their travel. Exact fare rises will not be confirmed until the July Retail Prices Indexconsumer inflation measure is released by the Office for National Statistics on Wednesday. However, economists at both Investec and EY Item Club both forecast that the figure, which the Department f...
Society
There is no new money in thegovernment’s flagship £100mfund to eradicate rough sleeping within a decade, the housing secretary has admitted - writes independent.co.uk Charities had welcomed the fund as a significant step towards helping the estimated 4,751 people sleeping rough on English streets on any given night. But speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, James Brokenshire said the cash had been“reprioritised” from existing budgets in his department...