Breast screen error 'could have been spotted earlier'

Thousands more women in England may have missed out on breast screening invitations dating back further than previously thought, according to a leading cancer expert.

Earlier this month, the health secretary said a 2009 computer failure may have shortened up to 270 lives  - writes bbc.com

But Prof Peter Sasieni said the problems go back to 2005, and could have been spotted earlier.

Public Health England said the analysis was "flawed".

And it said an independent review would look at all aspects of the breast screening service.

PHE discovered in January that some women aged 68-71 had not received their final invitation for breast screening.

Jeremy Hunt told the Commons that 450,000 women were affected between 2009 and the start of 2018.

Prof Sasieni, professor of cancer prevention at King's College London, looked closely at data from the breast cancer screening programme in England from 2004 to 2017 in a letter published in The Lancet .

Image copyright GETTY IMAGES Image caption Early detection of breast cancers offers the best chance of survival

He found that the proportion of 65-70 year old eligible women invited for screening was consistently less than those invited aged 55-64, dating back to 2004-05 when the programme was first extended to include women up to their 71st birthday.

A third of eligible women should have been invited every year - but the data shows it was 31% in 2006-07, increasing to nearly 35% in 2016-17.

In comparison, more women in younger age groups were invited each year.

The difference amounts to 140,000 between 2005 and 2008 - adding up to a total of more than 502,000 missing out since 2005, Prof Sasieni concluded.

Prof Sasieni, who is also lead investigator of the Cancer Research UK programme in cancer screening and statistics, said: "Data that could have alerted people to the lack of invitations being sent to women aged 70 was publicly available, but no one looked at it carefully enough."

Although the error should not be seen as "a major public health failure" and women should not feel anxious, he said it was right "to investigate how this error occurred and why it was not spotted for so long".

He added: "It is important that the computer systems used to run our cancer screening programmes are reviewed and, if necessary replaced - and that detailed anonymous data are made available for independent scrutiny."

'Important facts'

Prof John Newton, director of health improvement at Public Health England, said: "This is a flawed analysis which fails to take into account some important facts, such as when the breast screening programme was rolled out to all 70 year olds in England or when a clinical trial was started called Age X."

This trial looked at offering screening to women from 47 up to the age of 73 to see what the risks and benefits would be.

Prof Newton said their top priority was making sure that all women who did not receive an invitation for a screen were supported.

Baroness Delyth Morgan, chief executive at Breast Cancer Now, said it was "concerning" to hear that even more women could have been affected by missed screening invitations.

"We urge Public Health England to make clear the full extent of the error as soon as possible," she said.

The risk of breast cancer increases with age and screening helps early detection of cancers, offering the best chance of survival.

But it is not yet known whether for women over 70 the long-term benefits of screening outweigh the risks.

Read more news of London on our site.

bbc.com
health Breastscreen
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
I recommend
No recommendations yet

Comments

Comments are designed to communicate and discuss the features of an enterprise or event, as well as to find out the interesting questions on it.

Society
The U.S. and President Donald Trump has slapped a 15 per cent tariff on all steel and aluminum it receives from Canada, and if that rises to 25 per cent as has been threatened, it will cost more for the city to build its bridges and buildings with steel from the U.S. “We are trying to estimate a worst-case scenario,” said city treasurer Anna Lisa Barbon. “If there is a significant tariff increase, what impact would it have?” While the tariff is on steel sh...
Society
A teenage girl was raped in broad daylight in an east London park, police have said. The Met's child abuse and sexual offences command is investigating the attack, which happened in West Ham Park on Tuesday. The female victim was attacked by a man close to the entrance opposite FairlandRoad, Scotland Yard said. It happened at about 4pm. No arrests have yet been made. West Ham Park, which dates back to the 16th century,is run by the City of London Corporati...
Society
The number of homes in London will need to rise by a quarter within 25 years to cope with its rising population,official figures showed today. In a dramatic indication of the scale of the challenge, the Office for National Statistics said an extra 844,000 new households will be formed here by 2041 if current trends continue. That amounts to a 24 per cent increase on the existing total and would give London — which now has about 3.4 million households — a n...
Society
Earlier this summer, Yoshua Bengio, the McGill-based Artificial Intelligence pioneer and one of the world’s leading authorities on neural networks and machine-learning, added his name to a growing global list of experts and laboratories in the field that are pledging to have no role in the creation of what are called “lethal autonomous weapons” (LAWs). The signatories’ premise is as benign as it is unsound: that machines must never be given the authority t...
Society
Mayor of London Sadiq Khan has said he cannot be sure when Crossrail will be complete. Mr Khan said he will talk about a revised timetable at some stage, but only when he has confidence in it. It was announced on August 31 that the capital's new east-west railway would open in autumn 2019 rather than December this year. Mr Khan previously revealed that he only learned of Crossrail's delay two days before the announcement. The mayor was asked on BBC Radio L...
Society
Just weeks into a new school year, Western University and its roughly 1,650 faculty members are locked in a contractdispute, with faculty taking a strike vote among its members. But if there’s potential for labour disruption, it’s news to many students still easing into their new academic routines. “We literally had no clue,” said Melissa Trueman, a fifth year student at the university. “Students are trying to accomplish a goal but they can’t do it if thei...
Society
A large group of Uber Eats drivers blocked a road in east London today as they staged a protest over pay. Protesters said it was a spontaneous show of action against the company, as drivers claimed rates for every delivery had been reduced without it being agreed first. An Uber Eats spokesman said the firm has made changes to its payment structure in London in response to feedback from couriers. "As we transition to the new system, we're introducing minimu...
Crime
A gunman has open fired on a north London street, leaving two injured and reported holes in a taxi window. Armed police were deployed to Islington on Thursday evening, at about 9.30pm, after witnesses reported hearing gun shots and people running from the area. The suspect then fled the scene, on Essex Road, police said. Officers found two people – a 34-year-old woman and a 40-year-old man – suffering from minor injuries. The woman, police added, was taken...
Society
A businessman and his family were targeted in an arson attack which police are treating as a suspected race hate crime. Mac Karlekar, 44, and his wife and 15-year-old son fled their home in Orpington after their hedge was set on fire. Mr Karlekar has told how he was woken up in the early hours of the morning by neighbours, who were alerted by the “uncontrollable” barking of their dog Maggie. The neighbours opened their window and saw the blaze, then they c...