Westminster terror attack: 'How could Keith have been left alone?'

The widow of the police officer killed during the Westminster attack says her husband was left "in a vulnerable location, with no protection, to die".

It comes after the coroner said Keith Palmer's death on 22 March last year could "possibly" have been prevented if armed officers had been nearby.

"Shortcomings in the security system" meant they were unaware they should have been on guard near his position.

All five victims of the terror attack were "unlawfully killed", he ruled.

They were PC Palmer, 48, Kurt Cochran, 54, Leslie Rhodes, 75, Aysha Frade, 44, and Andreea Cristea, 31.

Their killer, Khalid Masood, was shot dead by police just inside the entrance to the Palace of Westminster. The inquest into his death will take place next.

What did the coroner say?

Chief Coroner Mark Lucraft QC, at the Old Bailey, has carried out the month-long inquests of those who died.

Giving his ruling on Wednesday, he praised the "great dignity" of their families throughout the process and also the "quite overwhelming" response from medics and members of the public.

He said that on on 22 March 2017, Masood had driven a hired SUV at an average speed of 30 to 42mph with "clear murderous intent", killing four pedestrians and seriously injuring 29 others, before attacking PC Palmer.

The coroner highlighted the actions of one victim, Mr Cochran, whom he said had "pushed his wife away from the path of Masood's vehicle" - "an instinctive act" which "almost certainly had the effect" of saving her life.

As part of the inquest, the coroner has also been examining security issues, including armed policing at Parliament, security on the bridge and what security service MI5 knew about Masood prior to his attack.

He said PC Palmer had been "fulfilling his job to protect the Palace and those within it" and "did not shrink from" performing that duty.

He was wearing a protective vest but was not armed, and the coroner said that had armed officers been stationed alongside him, they may have been able to prevent him suffering fatal injuries.

How have relatives reacted?

PC Palmer's widow, Michelle Palmer, said in a statement that the authorities let her husband down by failing to protect him and let the family down by failing to investigate his death properly.

She said: "How could Keith have been left alone, unarmed, guarding an open gate at one of the most iconic buildings in the world and one of the country's top terrorist targets?"

She added: "What makes it even worse is that this lax security had been carrying on for years and it has taken what happened to Keith for things to change."

The parents and sisters of PC Palmer, who would have turned 50 on Wednesday, said the inquest had been "traumatic" and "extremely difficult".

They said the coroner should have gone further in his findings, accusing senior Met officers of closing ranks.

What's the police's response?

Neil Basu, head of counter-terror policing at Scotland Yard, said the Met accepted the coroner's conclusions "unreservedly".

He said: "Even the possibility that the Met lost the chance to prevent the murder of such a brave and courageous officer is unacceptable. For the loss of that possibility… we are deeply sorry."

Security arrangements had been "substantially changed" since that day, he added, and further changes would be made if recommended by the coroner.

Graphic showing how Westminster attack unfolded

The attack lasted82 seconds.

  • 14:40:08- Masood's car mounts pavement on Westminster Bridge and hits pedestrians
  • 14:40:18- It hits another group of pedestrians and the impact sends Andreea Cristea over the side and into the river
  • 14:40:38- Masood crashes into perimeter fence of Palace of Westminster
  • 14:40:59- First 999 call made to Met police
  • 14:41:30- Masood leaves vehicle, stabbed PC Palmer, and is shot dead

Who were the victims?

Clockwise from top left - PC Keith Palmer, Aysha Frade, Leslie Rhodes, Andreea Cristea and Kurt Cochran

Image copyrightMET POLICE/SOCIAL MEDIAImage captionClockwise from top left: PC Keith Palmer, Aysha Frade, Leslie Rhodes, Andreea Cristea and Kurt Cochran all lost their lives

PC Keith Palmerhad a young daughter. He was a member of the parliamentary and diplomatic protection squad who had served with the Met for 15 years.

Aysha Fradehad been walking across Westminster Bridge to pick up her two young daughters from school when she was killed. The British national worked as a PA at a nearby independent sixth-form.

Leslie Rhodesa retired window cleaner from Clapham, south London, had been visiting St Thomas' Hospital when he was hit by the car driven by Masood.

Kurt Cochranfrom the US state of Utah, was in London as part of a holiday celebrating 25 years of marriage to Melissa, who was seriously injured in the attack.

Andreea Cristeawas a Romanian tourist. She had been with her boyfriend, Andrei Burnaz, who had been planning to propose to her that day.

Westminster attack London Westminster attack inquest
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
1 view in november
I recommend
No recommendations yet


Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

Children living in London boroughs with high diesel pollution suffer from stunted lung capacity, putting them at risk of early death, a study has said. Pupils living in areas that failed to meet EU nitrogen dioxide limits were at increased risk of lung disease, researchers found. The research studied 2,000 London school children over five years. "We are raising a generation of children reaching adulthood with stunted lungs," researchers said. Academics fro...
A private school teacher has been left partially blind after another woman smashed a glass in her face during a night out.  Lisa Bertsch, 30, was at the Be At One bar in Richmond when she was hit in her right eye. The tumbler shattered and left Ms Bertsch, who lives with her boyfriend in Kingston, needing emergency surgery. She said the attack happened when she tried to stop the assailant pouring a cocktail over her friend’s belongings. Ms Bertsch added th...
Discarded syringes have been left in play areas and car parks as a BBC investigation found councils were being called 50 times a day to remove them. Figures obtained by the BBC showed councils handled 18,496 cases in 2017-18, a rise of 7% in two years. A volunteer pricked by a discarded needle has told how he faces a wait for HIV and hepatitis test results. The Department for Communities and Local Government said it was "committed to doing more to reduce d...
The German Zeppelin bombing campaign of London during WWI has been brought to the fore again days before the centenary of the war in a film made by schoolchildren. The first ever example of strategic bombing in history - a tactic used in total war with the goal of defeating the enemy by destroying their morale or economy - was during the First World War Emperor Kaiser Wilhelm II initially banned attacks on the capital because of his close connection to the...
London’s busiest train station has recruited a hawk to scare off pigeons following a spate of complaints from angry passengers. Aria, a five-year-old harris hawk, has begun patrolling Waterloostation in a bid to stop people having to “fight" off pigeons while eating. There are 27 food and drink retailers at the Network Rail-managed station, and many customers have complained about pigeons pecking at food and leaving a mess. The birds have been pictured sit...
London City Airport is going to fine airlines for breaching noise limits after a surge in complaints from residents.  The airport, based in the Royal Docks, has launched a “penalty and incentive” scheme for planes breaching its rules, and will name and shame them online. Bosses revealed the airport had seen a spike in complaints since launching concentrated flight paths in February 2016. The paths were changed after new air traffic control technology was b...
The Crossrail delay will cost Transport for London almost £200 million next year in lost revenue, the Standard has learned. Latest calculations suggest the expected nine-month delay to the completion of the Elizabeth Line, first revealed in August, will cost the cash-strapped body almost £550,000-a-day.  TfL, which has a deficit of around £1bn, has told the London Assembly it will miss out on £170million income from passenger fares and up to £20million in...
Motorists who park in cycle lanes in one of London’s “Mini Holland” boroughs could have their residents’ parking permits revoked, council chiefs warned today. A crackdown on illegal parking has been launched by Waltham Forest council amid growing anger at the way some drivers are blocking the new routes.  They are being introduced under a £30 million initiative to encourage walking and cycling by building Dutch-style segregated routes, including a three-mi...
‘Only a bloody stark raving alcoholic is bloody drunk at 1.30pm in the afternoon,’ says Air India pilot. A senior Air India pilot was grounded after he failed breathalyser tests shortly before a flight from New Delhi to London on Sunday. Arvind Kathpalia, who is responsible for safety at the airline as operations director, denied drinking on the job and said he would contest the results of the alcohol checks. “It was 1.30pm in the afternoon, only a bloody...